In the complex and often unpredictable landscape of Australia’s housing market, the latest assessments reveal a cautious optimism tempered by several economic realitiesAnalysts, including those from ANZ, led by economists Madeline Dunk and Adelaide Timbrell, have shared their forecasts that suggest modest growth in property prices across the capital cities in 2024. However, this projection appears rather muted when compared to the growth periods of previous years, raising questions about what is causing stagnation in a time of economic recovery.

According to ANZ’s predictions, if the Reserve Bank of Australia (RBA) begins a rate-cutting cycle this week, property prices in Australia’s major cities might experience a slight uptick of only 0.9% for the yearThis figure contrasts sharply with the double-digit growth witnessed during the country’s property booms, signaling a far more subdued market climateMajor cities like Sydney and Melbourne, which have historically been the epicenters of the country’s housing growth, could even see slight declines in property valuesThe core of this forecast lies in two major factors: the limited scope of anticipated interest rate cuts and the persistent undersupply of housing.

The first of these factors, interest rates, is perhaps the most visible aspect of the current housing conversationWhile the RBA has hinted at potential rate cuts, the general sentiment among economists is that these reductions will be relatively minorANZ predicts two cuts of 0.25% each, which, though significant, are unlikely to cause a drastic shift in the housing marketThere is even an expectation in the market for a third rate cut, but the overall magnitude of these changes still falls short of what might be needed to stimulate significant buyer demandFor potential homebuyers, a small reduction in interest rates is unlikely to move the needle much when compared to the astronomical property prices they would need to finance

Advertisements

In other words, even if mortgage rates drop slightly, the sheer cost of purchasing a home remains prohibitively high for many Australians. 

Consider a young couple hoping to buy their first home in Sydney or Melbourne, cities that have some of the highest property prices in the countryWhile a 0.25% reduction in interest rates might ease monthly repayments, it would do little to alleviate the fundamental financial strain they would face when trying to secure a propertyIn this context, the modest rate cuts that are being speculated upon are not likely to be a panacea for the broader issues plaguing the housing market.

The second factor contributing to the stagnation in property prices is the ongoing shortage of available housingWhile building approvals for 2024 have seen a 12% year-on-year increase, this has not been enough to address the deep-seated undersupply of homes across the countryThe shortage remains particularly acute in high-demand urban areas like Sydney, Melbourne, and BrisbaneThis imbalance between supply and demand has created a situation where even slight increases in housing production do not fully address the needs of the marketTo use an analogy, it is like offering a famished person a single cracker after a long period of hunger; the immediate need remains unmetSimilarly, the long-standing housing supply deficit cannot be resolved with incremental changes, as demand continues to outpace supply.

In light of these challenges, there is, however, a faint sense of hope emerging from the Australian real estate sectorCampbell Hanan, CEO of Mirvac, has pointed out that buyer sentiment is beginning to shift as the potential for interest rate cuts becomes more tangibleMirvac, a prominent property developer, has seen a notable increase in contract volumes, with a 51% rise in residential lot contracts and a 36% increase in inquiries for new homes over the last six months of 2023. This uptick in activity, although still somewhat muted, suggests that there is a degree of latent demand that could be unlocked if the economic conditions improve slightly.

Moreover, major property developers such as Lendlease have reported strong presales across several significant apartment developments in Sydney and Melbourne

Advertisements

With a total presale volume of AUD 3 billion, these results highlight the continuing appeal of property as an investment class in the face of broader economic uncertaintiesThese presales suggest that, despite the broader cooling of the market, there is still a solid base of demand from both investors and homebuyers, particularly in well-established urban centers.

At the same time, progress is being made on addressing the critical issue of housing affordability by improving supplyThe construction industry has faced its own set of challenges, including rising costs and a lack of available subcontractors, which have slowed down development timelines and raised the cost of building new homesHowever, there are signs that conditions are beginning to improveThe availability of subcontractors is gradually returning to previous levels, and the number of insolvencies within the sector has decreasedMany subcontractors who had previously focused on large government infrastructure projects are now shifting their focus to residential construction, thereby increasing the pool of labor available to developers.

This shift in the labor market is significant, as it helps address one of the primary bottlenecks in the housing construction processHanan notes that there has been a noticeable resurgence of competitive energy during the early phases of construction, signaling a potential revival in the pace of developmentIf this trend continues, it could ultimately lead to a greater supply of housing in key markets, which would alleviate some of the pressures that have kept prices high.

However, the issue of rising construction costs remains a concernAs developers continue to face higher input costs, particularly for materials and labor, there is a growing need to adjust pricing structures in order to maintain profitabilityWhile not all buyers are willing to accept higher prices, certain projects have continued to attract strong demandFor instance, Mirvac’s Harbourside project in Darling Harbour achieved an impressive AUD 700 million in presales within just three days

Advertisements

Advertisements

Advertisements